*ePortfolio is best viewed on Desktop*
Leadership
Background and Context:
Recruiting male participants for research projects on mental health and physical well-being presents substantial challenges. This issue affects many research studies and college programs, including the Dietary Guidelines: 3 Diets (DG3D) study I collaborated in. One of the main reasons for this difficulty is the belief that males are less concerned with topics often perceived as uncomfortable or outside traditional gender norms. These deeply ingrained societal expectations play a significant role in hindering male participation and retention in research studies. Ultimately this can affect general population results from said research studies.
My work with DG3D and my experience in PSYC 221: Research Methods in Psychology gave me a great deal of insight into how gendered expectations affect study involvement and engagement with mental and physical health issues. My studies on male recruitment tactics and my work with DG3D have given me a better understanding of the obstacles males have when trying to participate in programs like this, as well as how to overcome them. This is especially pertinent to the study of social dynamics and health psychology.
Defining the Problem
Due to conventional patriarchal standards that emphasize resilience and independence, many males are reluctant to participate in research studies especially in areas like health or emotional vulnerability. This challenge is amplified by individuals' reluctance to engage in sensitive discussions, especially when certain topics are perceived as unsuitable for them. Studies on male gender role conflict (GRC) emphasize these obstacles (Nagai, 2004). The idea that males should refrain from taking part in mental and physical health programs is reinforced by GRC, which results in unfavorable attitudes about help-seeking behaviors (Nagai, 2004). This hesitancy adds to an unbalanced sample in DG3D, which makes it challenging to comprehend the extent of health disparities for men. Furthermore, for an entire general population for research findings.
Solutions
A variety of approaches should be used to remove these obstacles and boost male participation.
1. Connecting Male Peer Teachers with Male Leaders: Research indicates that peer influence has a significant impact on behavior (Dalana et al., 2022). We may foster circumstances where males feel more at ease and supported by pairing male peer educators, such as Psychologists, Psychiatrists, and Mental Health Counselors, with male leaders (such fraternity presidents, university professors, corporate executives, or even male faculty members). Collaborating with male leaders in the DG3D project may help combat the stigma and uneasiness associated with male involvement.
2. Targeted Recruiting Based on Interests: Recruitment efforts should focus on topics that resonate with participants, such as technology, environmental sustainability, personal finance, fitness, and mental health and wellness. By emphasizing what resides with individuals, recruitment can tap into intrinsic motivation. Highlighting the long-term benefits of health interventions, such as a lower risk of diabetes, may make initiatives like DG3D more appealing to a diverse range of participants.
3. Active Recruitment Strategies: Recruitment efforts should incorporate direct announcements through email campaigns, social media posts, text message alerts, push notifications, and webinars to reach and engage potential participants. These methods emphasize the importance of understanding that each person can contribute to a solution. Organizing health workshops for peer-led recruitment events could make the recruitment process more interesting and intimate to increase the probability of involvement.
4. Emphasizing Men's Role as Allies: I gained a better understanding of how public health initiatives' framing of roles can affect research study participation in PSYC 498: Advanced Independent Study. We can encourage males to understand that their participation is not only vital for everyone but also for their own health by presenting them as vital allies in the fight against diseases like diabetes. Males can participate in research studies like DG3D, where they can actively contribute to solutions, helping to dispel preconceptions and challenge stereotypes in the process.
Implementation of Solutions
1. Connecting Peer Educators with Leaders: To conduct health-related seminars or group discussions, male peer educators in DG3D could be paired with examples stated before of male leaders. By highlighting the importance of engaging in research and promoting health prevention initiatives, these leaders could serve as role models, encouraging participation and fostering a supportive learning environment.
2. Targeted Recruiting Based on Interests: Recruitment materials for DG3D could highlight a range of health benefits, such as improved overall wellness, long-term fitness goals, mental clarity, disease prevention, and increased longevity. These aspects may appeal to males interested in a holistic approach to health and well-being. Advertisements, emails, or fliers about fitness and health issues could be posted in coffee shops, bookstores, community centers, tech meetups, and other venues where individuals commonly gather.
3. Active Recruitment Strategies: Personalized follow-up emails or phone calls could be used to invite people to join the study following events such as diabetes prevention workshops or blood tests. Behavioral reinforcement techniques can encourage males to participate by providing immediate feedback and clearly communicating the potential benefits of their involvement for both their health and the success of the study.
4. Emphasizing Men’s Role as Allies: Stressing the importance of male participants in tackling mental health inequalities and focusing on improving physical health in DG3D recruitment materials may persuade more males to sign up. Making the participants feel more intimate and significant could involve emphasizing how their participation can close the gender gap in mental and physical health research participation and enhance healthcare for everyone.
Significance and Potential Impacts of Solutions
By implementing these tactics, we could significantly increase male participation in important research studies like DG3D, which focus on health-related topics that directly benefit men. Engaging males in these areas can help ensure more diverse perspectives and contribute to the overall success of these initiatives. Tailored interventions would result from more inclusive research that appropriately captures the needs and behaviors of all genders. Furthermore, fostering a cultural shift about men's involvement in health programs may assist in facilitating men's help-seeking behaviors which would eventually lead to healthier communities.
References
Dalana, A. R., Walsh, S., Hendon, W., Butler, M., Meschke, L. L., & McNeely, C. A. (2022). Barriers to recruitment and
retention of undergraduate men as college sexual assault prevention peer educators. Journal of American College Health, 72(4), 1200–1207. https://doi.org/10.1080/07448481.2022.2071618.
Nagai, S. (2024). Does male gender role conflict inhibit help‐seeking? Japanese Psychological Research, 66(3), 359–368.